The 8 May 2025 moment
On 8 May 2025, for his foundation's twenty-fifth anniversary, Bill Gates announces that he will give away virtually his entire fortune, roughly two hundred billion dollars by 2045, the year the foundation will close. The line is polished: "People will say a lot of things about me when I die, but I am determined that 'he died rich' will not be one of them." The announcement is applauded everywhere. It is, on the face of it, the most spectacular act of philanthropy in history.
And yet a fact resists the emotion. Since 2000, Gates has already transferred close to sixty-four billion dollars to his foundation. He divorced in 2021, with no prenuptial agreement, on a combined fortune estimated at one hundred and thirty billion. He gave, and gave again. The result: in 2025 his personal fortune still hovers between one hundred and one hundred and twenty billion dollars. Twenty-five years of massive giving, and he is roughly as rich as before. This anomaly is not a detail, it is the way into the subject.
Let me say it plainly: this article is not a prosecution, and Gates is neither the evil genius of the conspiracy sphere nor the secular saint of the television studios. He is more instructive than that: the best-documented instance of a legal, rational and almost invisible mechanism one may call the "charity business." To understand it, one has to hold together two truths that seem to exclude each other: this philanthropy genuinely saves lives, and it powerfully serves the person who practices it. Both are true at once, and that is exactly what makes it so hard to criticize. My thesis, in one sentence: at the scale of very large fortunes, the gift is not a machine for getting richer (the money is already there), it is a machine for converting money into power, partly financed by the taxpayer. Everything that follows has been verified, figure by figure; the few false numbers of the popular account are flagged along the way.
Sell the use, keep the ownership
To understand the man of 2025, one has to go back to the 1980 contract. IBM is looking for an operating system for its future personal computer; Microsoft, Gates's small company, does not have one. No matter: it buys an existing system, 86-DOS, nicknamed QDOS, from a Seattle firm. The popular account says "50,000 dollars." The real sum is seventy-five thousand, in two steps: twenty-five thousand in December 1980 for a license, fifty thousand in July 1981 for full rights.
The amount does not matter. What matters is the structure of the next contract. Microsoft does not sell its system to IBM: it grants a non-exclusive license, and keeps both ownership and the right to license it to any other manufacturer. When the PC "clones" multiply, they all need MS-DOS; within a year, more than seventy makers are paying Microsoft. IBM had seen a supplier, Gates had seen a tollbooth. Hold on to that gesture, because it is the invariant of the whole story: appear to divest, keep control in reality. Sell the use while keeping ownership in 1980; forty years later, the same gesture transposed: give away the capital while keeping governance.
(For those who like detail: the boost from Mary Gates, Bill's mother, who sat on the United Way board alongside IBM's John Opel, is real but overstated. She eased access, she did not create the contract.)
The mechanics of the circuit
The heart of the matter is neither illegal nor hidden: it is the perfectly rational use of a tax architecture specific to United States law. It comes down to five levers.
| Lever | Rule | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Deduction at entry | Gift deductible up to 30% of income; giving appreciated securities also avoids tax on the gain. | Tax falls at once. |
| 2. Retained control | The money leaves personal wealth but enters a trust the donor governs. | Divested on paper, decision-maker in practice. |
| 3. Minimum payout | An obligation to distribute only 5% of assets a year, operating costs included. | Most of the endowment stays invested. |
| 4. Lightly taxed capital | Investment income taxed at 1.39% since 2020 (not 1.86%, a figure often wrongly repeated). | Above a 5% return, the endowment grows net of tax. |
| 5. Neutralized inheritance | Assets held in the structure escape estate tax (40% federal). | Control passes on without the levy. |
Put end to end, the last three levers produce a result that looks paradoxical: as long as the endowment earns more than it pays out, it grows, net of tax, despite the gifts. This is not speculation, it is measured. In 2010, Gates and Warren Buffett launch the Giving Pledge, through which billionaires promise to give away most of their fortune. Fifteen years later, the Institute for Policy Studies did the math: the thirty-two original American signatories still billionaires have grown 283% richer since their pledge, reaching nine hundred and eight billion dollars combined. The gift slows the growth of capital, it does not reverse it. And of the roughly two hundred and six billion dollars actually given by these signatories, about 80% landed in private foundations and intermediary funds the donor still controls: the money "given" does not really leave the hand that gives it.
A worked case, to fix orders of magnitude
The simplest way to grasp the mechanism is to put numbers on a textbook case. Picture a top-bracket taxpayer who transfers to their foundation publicly traded shares worth one hundred million dollars, bought for almost nothing (almost entirely latent gain). Set clear assumptions: income tax at 37%, capital gains at 20%, estate tax at 40%, the deduction fully used. The calculation follows the Institute for Policy Studies method, which avoids double counting by applying estate tax only to the residual.
| What happens | Computation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Income-tax reduction | 37% of 100M | 37M USD |
| Capital gain never taxed | 20% of 100M | 20M USD |
| Subtotal already subsidized | 37 + 20 | 57M USD |
| Left to the donor | 100 - 57 | 43M USD |
| Estate tax avoided | 40% of 43M | 17M USD |
| Financed by the public | 37 + 20 + 17 | about 74M USD |
| Net cost to the donor | 100 - 74 | about 26M USD |
In other words: a "gift" advertised at one hundred million truly costs the donor only about twenty-six million; the remaining seventy-four are revenue the state forgoes. The figure of $0.74 per dollar is an upper bound, reached when all three advantages stack; it would be lower in intermediate cases. And the story does not end there, because the hundred million stays invested. At an 8% return and a 5% payout, the endowment earns eight million in the first year, pays out five (costs included), pays 1.39% tax on its income, about one hundred thousand dollars, and ends the year near one hundred and three million. The machine distributes, and grows all the same. That, in numbers, is the paradox of 8 May.
What the taxpayer pays
Here is the least intuitive point, and the one I want to press. The citizen signs no check to the billionaire, and yet pays. A tax deduction is a disguised public expenditure: when the state lets you deduct a gift, it forgoes a tax, and that missing money has to be found elsewhere, or a service given up. Economists call it a "tax expenditure," and budget-wise it is the same as a subsidy. The only difference is form: with a subsidy, parliament votes the destination; with a deduction, the donor alone chooses it. The hole in the budget is identical, but no one voted for the cause.
The hole is filled in three ways, all paid by the ordinary taxpayer: others pay more, the state borrows, or public services shrink. And the system is, to my mind, doubly unfair, because it is regressive: the richer the donor, the more the public tops up the gift. A modest earner who gives a hundred is lightly taxed, the state adds almost nothing; a billionaire who gives a hundred is topped up by as much as seventy-four. As the philosopher Rob Reich puts it, "the wealthier you are, the cheaper it is to be virtuous." So the taxpayer pays twice: once in money, to fill the hole; once in power, since in exchange for that public money he has no say over where it goes. (In France the mechanism exists, but capped: the "74 cents" effect is far more limited.)
From the check to power
If the donor does not really get richer and the taxpayer pays, what is the machine for? For turning money, abundant and volatile, into power, rare and durable. Because an earmarked gift is not a neutral transfer: it comes with an allocation the recipient cannot change. Global health shows this starkly. Since the United States withdrew from the World Health Organization, enacted in 2025-2026, the Gates Foundation has become its largest funder. With all its grants earmarked, it is the one that decides: over 2000-2024, 82.6% of its funds went to infectious diseases, 58.9% to polio alone, and under 1% to non-communicable diseases, which nonetheless cause 74% of deaths worldwide. This is not a management error, it is a private preference overriding a public priority.
African agriculture tells the same story. The AGRA program, launched in 2006 by the Gates and Rockefeller foundations with nearly one billion dollars, promoted costly seeds and fertilizers that made smallholders dependent on outside suppliers. A Tufts University assessment finds it: in the countries concerned, the number of people going hungry rose by about 30% between 2006 and 2018, and yields grew only 18%, far short of the promised doubling, a goal quietly removed from the website in 2020. Climate and demography play their part too, but the gap between the promise and the result is documented.
A critique as old as the object
None of this is new. The model goes back to Andrew Carnegie and his Gospel of Wealth (1889): the rich man has a duty to redistribute his fortune in his lifetime, but according to his own judgment. John D. Rockefeller industrializes it in 1913, and already Congress refuses the federal charter of his foundation, seeing in it a "concentration of power" contrary to democracy. The critique is thus as old as the thing. Recent scholarship has sharpened it: Rob Reich (Just Giving, 2018) describes a power "largely unaccountable, near-perpetual and lavishly tax-advantaged"; Anand Giridharadas (Winners Take All, 2018) shows an elite that funds only the change compatible with its own position; Linsey McGoey (No Such Thing as a Free Gift, 2015) reminds us that only a handful of American foundations are audited each year; and the journalist Tim Schwab (The Bill Gates Problem, 2024) documents, with evidence, the influence exerted over public policy.
True and false
Understanding the real mechanism makes the fantasy unnecessary, and that is fortunate, because the conspiracy theories about Gates are false. The famous line from the 2010 TED talk, where he supposedly "wants to eliminate the population," is a distortion: he is talking about lowering population growth by 10 to 15% through better child health (children who survive mean families who have fewer), which FactCheck.org and PolitiFact have confirmed. He neither "funded" nor "planned" Covid; his 2015 warning about pandemic risk was an analysis, not a guilty premonition.
The truth, by contrast, is enough on its own: Gates did associate with Jeffrey Epstein several times between 2011 and 2014, that is after the 2008 conviction, meetings he called a "grave error in judgment" and which Melinda French Gates cites, in her 2025 memoir, among the reasons for the divorce. Incidentally, the figure of 76 billion often attributed to her in that divorce is false: it comes from an estimate of the combined fortune; documented transfers are around twenty-five billion according to Forbes. And the good done, finally, is real: polio has nearly disappeared thanks in large part to the foundation's funding, and hundreds of millions of children have been vaccinated. The pattern does not erase that good; it only explains why it is decided by a single person rather than by a collective process.
The circuit, in one sentence
In the end, the pattern is strikingly simple. The "charity business" is a closed circuit, and none of its steps durably decapitalizes the donor.
| Step | Effect |
|---|---|
| 1. Give | the asset leaves the personal estate |
| 2. Deduct | tax falls at once (up to $0.74 per dollar) |
| 3. Control | kept through the trust |
| 4. Growth | the endowment, taxed at 1.39%, keeps growing |
| 5. Power | influence and reputation, which restart the cycle |
The cost is socialized, the decision stays private. So the real question is not whether these people are generous. It is whether a democracy should delegate, and subsidize, the private exercise of a power as vast as a public policy, to actors no one has elected. Gates's promise to give it all away by 2045 will be, in its way, the real-world test.

